Steel Expansion Tank or Membrane Expansion Tank?

What Is an Expansion Tank?
An expansion tank is a component used in mechanical systems to balance pressure.
When the water inside the system heats up, its volume expands. If this expansion is not controlled:
- pressure rises
- the system can be damaged
- equipment can malfunction
The expansion tank absorbs this excess volume and balances the system pressure.
Expansion tanks are used especially in the following systems:
- booster pump systems
- central heating systems
- boiler rooms
- underfloor heating systems
- solar energy systems
What Is a Steel Expansion Tank?
A steel expansion tank is a tank that contains no membrane and consists entirely of a steel body.
In these tanks, water and air occupy the same space.
When the water in the system expands, the air inside the tank is compressed and balances the pressure.
Advantages
- can be used in large systems
- tanks with high volume can be produced
- long service life
Disadvantages
- air can mix into the water over time
- air can form in the system
- requires maintenance
For this reason, steel expansion tanks are generally used in large boiler rooms.
What Is a Membrane Expansion Tank?
In membrane expansion tanks, water and air are separated from each other by a rubber membrane.
The tank contains two sections:
- water section
- air section
Thanks to the membrane, water and air do not mix.
Advantages
- requires no maintenance
- no air forms in the system
- provides more stable pressure
- ideal for booster pump systems
Disadvantages
- the membrane can wear out over time
- can be expensive in very large capacities
Which Tank Is Used in Booster Pump Systems?
In booster pump systems, membrane expansion tanks are generally used.
Because these tanks:
- keep the pressure more stable
- prevent the pump from switching on too frequently
- require no maintenance
For this reason, the membrane tank is preferred in residential and apartment booster pump systems.
Which Tank Is Used in Central Heating Systems?
Both tank types can be used in central heating systems.
However, in modern systems, generally:
the membrane expansion tank
is used.
How Is Expansion Tank Capacity Selected?
The following parameters should be considered when selecting an expansion tank:
- system water volume
- working pressure
- maximum temperature
- safety margin
An incorrect tank choice can cause pressure problems in the system.
Expansion Tank Brands
There are many quality expansion tank manufacturers on the market.
The brands frequently preferred at POMEKA are as follows:
- Varem expansion tanks
- Reflex expansion tanks
- Zilmet expansion tanks
- Cimm expansion tanks
- Aquasystem tanks
These brands offer reliable solutions for booster pump and heating systems.
Why Does an Expansion Tank Fail?
Some problems can occur in expansion tanks over time.
The most common problems are:
- membrane rupture
- drop in air pressure
- corrosion inside the tank
These problems can cause the booster pump system to switch on continuously.
How Many Bar Should the Air Pressure Be in a Membrane Tank?
In membrane tanks, the air pressure is generally set within the following range:
1.5 – 2 bar
This value should be adjusted according to the system pressure.
Which Is Better: Steel Tank or Membrane Tank?
In residential and booster pump systems, membrane expansion tanks are generally more advantageous.
Because:
- requires no maintenance
- no air forms in the system
- provides more stable pressure
However, steel expansion tanks can be used in very large boiler rooms.
Conclusion
Choosing the right expansion tank is very important for the efficient operation of the system.
In general:
- residential and booster pump systems → membrane tank
- large boiler systems → steel tank
are preferred.
A correctly selected expansion tank prevents pressure problems in the system and extends the equipment's service life.

POMEKA İş Ortakları - Teknik Bobinaj

Torque Calculation for Electric Actuated Valves

Difference Between On/Off and Proportional Motorized Valves

Electric or Pneumatic Valve? Which Is the Right Choice?

The 10 Most Common Mistakes When Choosing Motorized Valves

